Challenging the Ministry of Children and Family Development’s culture of risk and surveillance

We are calling on the BC government and Ministry of Children and Family Development (MCFD) to dismantle the framework for policing and surveilling families.

The current culture, policies, training, and tools that guide the family policing system in BC are profoundly harming families. Risk assessment tools perpetuate and reinforce colonial, racist, ableist, misogynistic, and classist biases. This has created a culture of risk and surveillance that upholds ongoing colonization in the lives of Indigenous children, youth, families, communities, and Nations.

Pink text on a purple background reads "Stop tearing families apart!" A graphic in the top right corner shows a child's hand reaching for a parent.

Without rooting out the current culture of risk and surveillance and investing in desperately needed structural supports for families, any proposed reforms will continue the legacy of tearing families apart and profoundly harming them.

In an open letter, West Coast LEAF, Keeping Families Together, PACK BC, YWCA Metro Vancouver, BC Association of Social Workers, and Raincity Housing urged then Premier John Horgan and members of the Select Standing Committee on Children and Youth to root out the culture of risk and surveillance at MCFD.

Alongside Keeping Families Together, PACK BC, YWCA Metro Vancouver, BC Association of Social Workers, Raincity Housing, Sanctuary Health, Pivot Legal Society, Native Women’s Association of Canada, BC Complex Kids, and Single Mothers’ Alliance of BC, we resent the open letter to Premier Eby, Hon. Mitzi Dean, and members of the Select Standing Committee on Children and Youth urging the BC government to show leadership in its approach to child and family well-being.

Read the open letter (PDF, 778kb).

Take action

Now is the time to challenge MCFD’s culture of risk and surveillance. Join us in calling on the BC government to stop tearing families apart!

MCFD’s culture of risk and surveillance has profound impacts on families and communities. Our gratitude to members of Keeping Families Together who shared their experiences of this harmful system.

White text on a purple background. A quote from a member of Keeping Families Together. "I have seen my family torn apart and seen the failure from MCFD in doing proper risk assessment of my own family members who were harming their children spiritually and emotionally. They whole system is designed to fail my people and as a result it is the new residential school." -Anonymous
The family policing systam is a modern-day residential school system. This has to stop! - rebecca
A quote from a member of Keeping Families Together. "MY husband came to the hospital and the social worker had told the nurses he wasn't allowed to be there, so they called the cops. The cops showed up and threw him around and put him in handcuffs and he went into psychosis. They didn't realize his situation, just assumed he was on drugs. He ended up in the psych ward and I had the baby alone through a C-section. They've been in our lives ever since." -Shannon
A quote from a member of Keeping Families Together. "Even when toxicology reports showed no alcohol and drugs, I was still labeled as a drunk, still stereotyped, it's not a system of innocent till proven guilty." -Robin

Understanding the culture of risk and surveillance

Challenging MCFD's culture of risk and surveillance visual primer.
Thank you to Michelle Buchholz of Cassyex Consulting for her inspired work on the visual primer!

Download the visual primer (PDF, 482kb).

Download a Word doc image description for the primer (.docx, 140kb).

Download a PDF image description for the primer (PDF, 463kb).

Learn more about our child welfare advocacy Communities of Practice project.

Submissions

Take action for justice and equity!

We need your help to make positive, transformative change.